Not everything worth ordering in September is at the festival. When you want the best cold coffee on property, the answer is Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs — and the order is the Original Peanut Butter Cold Brew.
What it is
Smooth oat-milk cold brew blended with a dark-roasted peanut blend from a Georgia peanut farm, sweetened with maple syrup. It's vegan and gluten-free, and it runs about $6.50. The peanut flavor is real and roasty rather than candy-sweet, which is exactly why it works — it drinks like a coffee, not a milkshake.
Where to get it
Gideon's Bakehouse, in The Landing neighborhood of Disney Springs — no park ticket required. It's the gothic cookie shop with the enormous, nearly half-pound cookies, and the cold brews were built to pair with them.
A peanut-butter coffee that isn't a sugar bomb, made to be chased with a chocolate cookie. That pairing is the whole reason to make the trip.
Why this one for September
It earns the month because it's the anti-festival pick — a calm, no-ticket, sit-in-the-shade order for when you want quality over spectacle. The vegan-and-gluten-free build also makes it one of the easiest coffees on property to recommend to almost anyone. Order it alongside the Original Chocolate Chip cookie and thank us later.
One perfect cold brew, and the cookie to pair it with.
It's one of the picks in Starlit Magic's coffee and café guides — the best cold brews, lattes, and specialty drinks across the parks and Disney Springs, mapped and ready when the afternoon slump hits.
📱 Download Starlit Magic — FreeOrder it this September
Cold, roasty, and cookie-ready. Skip the park line and go get one.